Ogbebor v. Philip Morris, USA, et al.

Summary

In this proceeding consolidating a pair of tobacco lawsuits, two smokers claim that defendant cigarette manufacturers are responsible for the smokers' lung cancer and laryngeal cancer by concealing the dangers of the cigarettes they manufactured.

Defendant Philip Morris contends that the smokers knew the risks of cigarettes but did not do enough to quit in time to avoid their diseases.

Defendant R.J. Reynolds contends that the smokers did not smoke enough of its cigarettes to contribute to the diseases that afflicted them.

Outcome

As to plaintiff Sharon Ogbebor's case against defendants Philip Morris USA and R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Co.:

For plaintiff Sharon Ogbebor against defendant Philip Morris USA.
For defendant R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company.

Apportionment of fault:
Plaintiff Sharon Ogbebor: 30%
Defendant Philip Morris USA: 70%

Total damages: $1,426,600
Recoverable damages after apportionment of fault: $998,620

As to plaintiff Howard and Kathleen Thompson's case against defendants Philip Morris USA and R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Co.:

For plaintiffs Howard and Kathleen Thompson against defendant Philip Morris USA.
For defendant R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company.

Apportionment of fault:
Plaintiff Howard Thompson: 40%
Defendant Philip Morris USA: 60%

Total damages: $1,170,000
Recoverable damages after apportionment of fault: $702,000