- Defense
- Amazon
- Defense
- Agora Logistics LLC
- Represented By:
- Healy, Robert (Melick & Porter, LLP)
Carnwath, et al. v. Amazon
VERDICT
Trial
07/20/26 – 07/22/26
Summary
A Massachusetts state court jury awarded $56 million on June 22 to an elderly man who suffered catastrophic injuries in a collision with an Amazon delivery van, beating a $20 million settlement offer.
The Middlesex County jury returned their verdict following a two-day trial in which Amazon and co-defendant Agora Logistics LLC stipulated liability for the 2024 accident that left plaintiff Malcolm Carnwath severely disabled with a traumatic brain injury, an amputated leg and requiring 24-7 nursing care. The collision occurred after driver Nazayah Carrasquillo crossed the center line and struck Carnwaths vehicle.
Outcome
$56,000,000.00 awarded to plaintiff
Blog Posts
$56M Amazon Crash Verdict Beats $20M Settlement Offer: Watch Full Trial via CVN
Jul 24, 2026
- Plaintiff
- Defense
- Verdict
- $56,000,000
- Case Number
- 2581CV01262
- Industry
- Automotive
- Practice Area
- Transportation
- Expert Witnesses
Sessions
AM Session
Openings
12 Chapters
PM Session
Closings
11 Chapters
PM Session
Verdict
2 Chapters
Recording Disclaimer: This proceeding was recorded in full.